Make your own free website on Tripod.com
Scoresheetwiz
Projected American League rotations for 2010
Home
Who is Scoresheetwiz?
Archived Commentary
Strategies
Most Useful Sites
Archived Analysis
Rules
Quick Links (revised)

sorted by "for sure", "probably", "respectable alternatives", "young challengers", "wild chance", "later", and "emergency only"

This is my 20th season playing a keeper league version of Scoresheet Baseball. That experience has taught me that it is extremely rare for a starting pitcher to pitch mostly in the lower levels of the minors one year then become a mainstay on the parent club the next. Even the most blue chip pitching prospects generally spend a year in AA or a half season in AA and AAA each. Last year, there were five pitchers who spent most of the season in the American League and spent most of their 2008 season at the high A level or lower. One, Brian Matusz of the Orioles, mostly pitched for his college and didn't make his official professional debut until this past season. Detroit's Rick Porcello debuted last year in the high A Florida State League. The bulk of Texas Ranger Derek Holland's 2008 innings were in the lower level Midwest League. His 2007 debut was in a short season league. Brett Anderson and Trevor Cahill have been locked together pitching most of 2007 in the Midwest League and most of 2008 in the high A California League before a late season call-up to the AA Texas League. Then both Anderson and Cahill spent all of 2009 in Oakland's rotation.

 

And those are just the American League starting pitchers. I haven't checked for relievers making the jump. There is no way we will have that many starters making such a leap this year. The top echelon of pitching prospects who haven't had a good stint at the highest Minor League levels are way too young and inexperienced (Jacob Turner, Martin Perez, Michael Ynoa). Perhaps, I've overlooked someone, but there are no A or A- AL pitching prospects who spent most of last year at the high A level.

 

Here are my substantially researched estimates for the American League starting rotations including those who have a reasonable shot at making their rotations at some point later in the season (excluding unforeseeable player transactions):

 

Yankees starters for sure:

Sabathia

Vazquez

Burnett

Pettitte

Probably:

Chamberlain

          Emergency only:

Gaudin

Aceves

Mitre

Sanchez, Romulo

          Later, perhaps:

Hughes

McAllister

Garcia, Christian

          Notes:

The Yankees seriously lack depth. The only viable alternatives beyond Gaudin are in their bullpen. Pitchers as old as Pettitte tend to break down. Vazquez was a smart pick-up because he is so durable. The same can't be said of Burnett and Chamberlain. I suspect they are treating Hughes with the kid gloves they used for Joba. Hence, they will want to hold off until deep into the season before handing him a starting role. (If the original five hold up, they won't bother.) It is not as though the Yankees haven't made a huge effort to develop starting pitchers. They stocked their system to the rafters with excellent pitching prospects. They just haven't been very successful in developing them.

 

Red Sox starters for sure:

Beckett

Lackey

Lester

Matsuzaka

          Probably:

Buchholz

          Young Challengers:

Tazawa

Bowden

          Emergency only:

Wakefield

Bonser

Ramirez, Ramon A.

          Notes:

Tazawa and Bowden are now passing Wakefield and are 20 years younger. The odds are probably higher that Boston will bid Wake a fond adieu than give him his job back in the rotation. There is not a chance of Casey Kelly leaping to the rotation, yet. He only just decided this December that his baseball "major" is pitching not shortstop. With Tazawa and Bowden in the fold, there is no reason to rush him.

 

Rays starters for sure:

Shields

Garza

Price

Niemann

          Probably:

Davis, Wade

          Respectable alternative:

Sonnanstine

          Young Challenger:

Hellickson

          Emergency only:

Hernandez, Carlos

          Later, perhaps:

McGee

Torres, Alexander

          Notes:

Like Wakefield, Sonnanstine lost his starting job last year and may never get it back and has been passed by a couple of young pitchers - actually four: David Price, Jeff Niemann, Wade Davis, and Jeremy Hellickson. Unlike Wakefield, Sonnanstine is not old (even for a knuckleballer) and could be useful for reasonable depth. Jake McGee should be well recovered now from Tommy John surgery, but will likely be converted into a reliever.

 

Blue Jays starters for sure:

Rzepczynski

Romero

          Probably:

Marcum

Morrow

Cecil

          Respectable alternative:

Tallet

          Young Challenger:

Stewart, Zach

          Emergency only:

Richmond

Purcey

Eveland

Mills, Brad

          Later, perhaps:

Litsch

McGowan

Drabek

          Notes:

Marcum needs to show a return to his previous level, which would make him the ace. Morrow must harness his huge potential into effectiveness. Zach Stewart will likely start in Las Vegas, but could overtake Romero or Cecil at any time. Kyle Drabek has even more upside, but further to get there. Litsch and McGowan are recovering from injuries. Due to conflicting reports, it is difficult to gauge how soon and how well they will recover. The Blue Jays' pitchers' frequency of injuries is as remarkable as their ability to come up with one decent pitcher after another.

 

Orioles starters for sure:

Matusz

Guthrie

Millwood

          Probably:

Tillman

Bergesen

          Young Challengers:

Britton

Arrieta

          Emergency only:

Hernandez, David

Berken

Hendrickson

          Later, perhaps:

Erbe

          Wild Chance:

Uehara

          Notes:

In a year or two, the Orioles may be hoping for a rotation of Matusz, Tillman, Britton, Arrieta, and Erbe with eventually Hobgood challenging for a spot. Erbe was supposed to be almost ready now, but was passed by several other Orioles pitching prospects. However, the 21 year old this past year in AA pitched quite well, Although, he was slowed down by shoulder fatigue. Some teams are better at developing their pitching prospects than others; and the Orioles do not seem to one of the better ones, although, they are highly invested in excellent pitching prospects at the moment. Koji Uehara is expected to convert to reliever.

 

Twins starters for sure:

Baker

Liriano

Slowey

Blackburn

Pavano

          Young Challenger:

Swarzak

          Emergency only:

Perkins

Duensing

Manship

          Wild chance:

Maroth

          Notes:

For a team once considered a team rich in pitching prospects, there doesn't seem to be much to like here with the Twins. A step further towards full recovery from Liriano is their only hope for an ace. Mike Maroth is in camp. After years of shoulder and other various physical issues, he is trying to come back to his pre-2006 mediocre self. It is too soon to wish for prized pitching prospect Kyle Gibson making the Majors this year. He is fresh out of college and hasn't thrown a pitch in the minors, yet.

 

Tigers starters for sure:

Verlander

Scherzer

Porcello

          Probably:

Bonderman

Galarraga

          Respectable alternative:

Robertson, maybe

          Emergency only:

Miner

Bonine

          Wild chance:

Willis

Coke

          Notes:

This could go very badly, though, complete comebacks from Bonderman, Robertson, and Willis would make the Tigers the favourites of the division. Unfortunately, there is only a small chance that will happen to any of them, let alone all three. Yet, I am optimistic, although admittedly a biased Tigers fan for most of my life. John Perrotto reported in Baseball Prospectus that the Tigers were pleased with Armando Galarraga's performance in Venezuela.  Phil Coke was apparently promised a trial conversion. It will be more than a year before Casey Crosby surfaces and likely longer for Jacob Turner.

 

White Sox starters for sure:

Peavy

Buehrle

Floyd

Danks, John

          Probably:

Garcia, Freddy

          Respectable alternatives:

Hudson, Daniel

Torres, Carlos

          Wild chance:

Cabrera, Daniel

          Emergency only:

Hynick

          Notes:

From 2001-2006 Freddy Garcia was a reliable 210+ inning pitcher. He hasn't logged as much a 60 innings in any season since. However, Garcia's strikeout, walk, HR, and Ground ball rates all looked normal for him in the 9 starts he gave his White Sox. Daniel Hudson rose very far very quickly and is realistically in a three way battle for the 5th spot with Garcia and Carlos Torres, who, though was never listed as a top 10 prospect, nonetheless dominated AAA last year with a 2.39 ERA and 130 strikeouts in 128 innings.

 

Indians starters:

          Probably:

Westbrook

Masterson

Carmona

Laffey

Huff

          Young Challengers:

Carrasco, Carlos

Rondon

          Wild chance:

Lewis, Scott

          Emergency only:

Sowers

Talbot

Ambriz

          Later, perhaps:

Reyes, Anthony

          Notes:

Sowers keeps getting long stints in the rotation all of which have proved that his respectable rookie 14 game starts in 2006 were beginner's luck (or the nice showing rookies often get before the league learns to exploit their weaknesses). Surely now he has run out of chances as a "respectable alternative". Though Condon and Carrasco might improve matters, help from their most promising pitching prospects Hagadone, Knapp, and Alex White are a long way away. If any of them soar up to the Indians this year, they would likely come as relievers.

 

Royals starters for sure:

Greinke

Meche

Hochevar

Bannister

Davies

          Respectable alternative:

Tejeda - better in pen

          Wild chance:

Campillo

Farnsworth

Chen

Parrish

          Emergency only:

Thompson, Brad

Humber

          Later, perhaps:

Montgomery

Crow

Duffy

          Notes:

Hochevar, Bannister, and Davies have not pitched consistently well enough to secure their places in a Major League rotation. It's just that the Royals don't have any practical alternatives. Robinson Tejeda and Brad Thompson seem to fit better in the bullpen. Phil Humber is a minor league veteran with occasional call-ups (don't know why), who's AAA ERA last year was 5.34 with a 6.54 K/9. Unless that current quintet of starters improves, the Royals will have to wait painfully for their top pitching prospects to sling through a couple levels of the minors. The best chance for that to happen is here.

 

Angels starters for sure:

Weaver

Kazmir

Pineiro

Santana, Ervin

Saunders

          Emergency only:

Palmer, Mike

Bell, Trevor

Stokes

O'Sullivan

Ortega

          Later, perhaps:

Reckling

Walden

          Notes:

Danger! Here we have an entire rotation with significant injury history and only very scary choices to fill in. Bell's ERA in AA and AAA last summer earned himself an August promotion to the Angels. His strikeout and groundball rates indicate those ERAs were heavily enhanced by fairy dust and his 9.74 ERA with the Angels confirmed it. Brian Stokes didn't start a game last year for the Mets. No wonder: his strikeout rate sank, while his walk rate soared so that they almost came to equal each other. Probably the Angels' top choice to be a substitute starter is Matt Palmer who had an almost equally weak K/BB (1.25) last year. At least he gets ground balls (1.5 GB/FB). Trevor Reckling and Jordan Walden both pitched mostly in AA last year and are better pitching prospects than anyone on the Angels' 40 man roster.

 

Rangers starters for sure:

Harden

Feldman

          Probably:

Holland

Hunter

McCarthy

          Respectable alternatives:

Lewis, Colby

Nippert

          Young Challengers:

Feliz

Harrison

Hurley

          Emergency only:

Moscoso

Mathis

          Later, perhaps:

Kiker

          Notes:

Until last year, fans wondered if the Rangers were capable of developing a quality major league pitcher. Then Scott Feldman and Tommy Hunter gave them surprisingly good seasons. Neftali Feliz has Rangers fans pumped. He most likely will be their future ace, but at 21 years old, they don't want to wear him out too soon. The season did not pan out so well for fellow highly hyped Derek Holland nor formally highly hyped Brandon McCarthy. They will have to do better as Colby Lewis returns from Japan with scouts applauding.

 

Mariners starters for sure:

Hernandez, Felix

Lee, Cliff

          Most likely:

Rowland-Smith

Snell

Fister

          Respectable alternative:

Vargas

          Young Challengers:

French

Olson, Garrett

          Wild chance:

Shell

          Emergency only:

Pauley

          Later, perhaps:

Bedard - later, for sure

Cortes, Dan

          Notes:

Every name under the Mariners above has been projected by once source or another as a most probable member of the rotation - except Daniel Cortes, a highly regarded prospect who has spent the last two seasons in AA - plus one other: Yusmeiro Petit, who has been designated for assignment. Other nearly ready prospects Rohrbaugh and Feierabend are recovering from injuries. King Felix, Cliff Lee, and Ryan Rowland-Smith made every list, Ian Snell: all but one. Of the rest, only Doug Fister made more than one list. Erik Bedard isn't expected to be recovered from his shoulder surgery, at least, until mid-season.

 

By the way, I don't use a poll of depth charts to decide who is most likely to be in the rotation. I do weigh the sites that are closest to actual inside sources the most and make a few common sense deductions myself.

 

Athletics starters for sure:

Anderson, Brett

Sheets

          Probably:

Duchscherer

Braden

Cahill

          Respectable alternatives:

Outman

          Young Challengers:

Gonzalez, Gio

Marzzaro

          Emergency only:

DiNardo

Mortensen

          Later, perhaps:

Simmons

          Notes:

Quite a lot would have to go wrong to get to pitching prospect James Simmons or someone else not listed, but this is a starting pitcher menu of two veterans with a very high injury risk (Ben Sheets and Justin Duchscherer) and youngsters who's limits haven't even been tested (Anderson, Dallas Braden, Trevor Cahill, etc.). Gio Gonzalez is highly regarded and seemingly ready for a serious challenge for a rotation spot. Clayton Mortensen could be the A's long reliever / spot starter this year.

John Carter