Site review: Depth Charts and Career MLB & Minor League Stats
Who is Scoresheetwiz?
Archived Commentary
Most Useful Sites
Archived Analysis
Quick Links (revised)

Winners: Rotoworld and a tie: Toronto Star & Baseball Cube

Of the sites I most frequently use for analyzing players during the off season, two (now three) have made significant recent improvements.


Career minor league statistics are crucially important to consider for any player who has been in the majors less than a couple years. Surprisingly, of the dozens of career players stats available for free on line, only a few carry career minor league stats. Only Rotoworld, Baseball America, and give you current minor league stats, but they won’t take you back any further in time. Baseball Cube is the only source for career minor league stats of retired players of the last 10 years or so, but that site is riddled with annoying pop-ups and ads from which there is no apparent escape.* The Toronto Star Player Index was my favorite until last year. It is completely clean and gives a little scouting report, describes transactions, call-ups/sent-downs, and DL stints along with their career Organized Baseball record. It has career high info that I don’t pay any attention to, but it is fun to see where a player was born and what he considers his home town. They lost my loyalty last year, because their name cross-referencing wasn’t working. You had to click on the letter representing their last name, then scroll down and find their name from there. CBS Sportsline worked better, though, the minor league stats are in a completely separate box at the bottom of a long page from the major league stats. There isn’t much else on that long page that is useful or particularly interesting. I do look at their player news sometimes, but there are better sources for analysis and injury updates. Their statistics are plentiful, but primitive. Toronto Star fixed their index, so I’m back with them, now. Besides, you have to pay to get ESPN’s scouting reports, so I use The Star’s unless I have better info from Baseball America or John Sickels.


*Correction Jan. ’07: Baseball Cube has been cleaned-up and is now an excellent site. It’s advantage over the Toronto Star site is that it gives the pitchers’ home runs, hits, walks, and strikeouts per 9 innings. Other nice bonuses are play-off stats, fielding stats, cross-referencing on players who are from the same home town, high school, or college. It even indicates to which organization the player’s minor league teams belongs and a season-by-season list of managers he played for. The strong points for the  Toronto Star are its scouting reports, injury history, and overall cleanness. For example, it is much easier to find and read the transactions associated with the player. The Baseball Cube is too busy with advertisements and a wonky layout. I do thank them for removing the most offending ads, however. And, if you look at Vernon Wells or Rich Harden, you can see I’ve been a supporter of theirs for a long time – when a lifetime sponsorship was ten or fifteen bucks!



Here in early January, I found only two Depth Charts Depth with data base links that are up-to-date with player movements: Rotoworld and Rotoworld has revamped their look after abandoning their old depth charts late in the season last year. Neither site has a master page such as CBS Sportsline’s. Both require selecting a team from any other team’s page. However, Rotoworld index is a bit wonky on my computer. has the much nicer index and the nicer graphic. You see the players distributed across a baseball field by position, while Rotoworld merely has them listed in rows and columns. shows who might play whichever other positions rather than just showing the members of the bench at only one position. Here is’s depth chart for the Blue Jays. The Rotoworld index which requires first clicking a drop down button that doesn’t even work right. Not all the teams show up and there are extraneous “player” choices.


However, in my opinion Rotoworld has far more realistic predictions of who will be starting where. The list below shows where they differ. After each comparison I call the winner. Note, I didn’t quibble over who was listed first through fourth in the rotation. That really doesn’t matter. However, the 5th starter is the one most likely to lose a job or at the very least, a few starts, so I did point out those differences. Both web sites often listed multiple pitchers in the 5th spot, although Rotoworld listed far more candidates.



Bal lf: Payton         Huff

Rotoworld. Close call. Huff might play some dh-1b possibly take over 3b from Mora leaving a greater number of games played in leftfield for Payton. However, unless Huff gets hurt, he will have more at bats than Payton, and for now, you can expect most of them will be in left.


Bal 5s: no R.Lopez     includes R.Lopez

Rotoworld: Lopez is surely a candidate with Loewen, and, at least, we see who will be available for the first injury


Chi 5s: neither        incl. Haeger and H.Phillips

Rotoworld: Gavin Floyd pitched 4.23 in AAA, 7.29 with the Phillies. Haeger was 3.07 and 3.44 (even after a disastrous first start). Phillips has a 2.96 ERA in AAA.


Cle 5s: incl. Carmona  no Carmona

Rotoworld: Although, it is nice to know who no. 6 is, there is no chance Sowers would lose his job to Carmona in the spring.


Det 5s: Verlander      Maroth (otherwise same five)

Rotoworld: Ridiculous. Although, Maroth could well get more starts for awhile due to Verlander’s tender young arm, if anyone is in danger of losing his job to Ledezma or Andrew Miller, it will be Maroth.


KC  3b: Teahen         A.Gordon

KC  rf: Sanders        Teahen

Rotoworld: The Royals could get sued if they kept Gordon in the minors any longer. You never know with this organization, but Sanders seems the most logical one to bench or cut.


KC  5s: incl. Elarton  no Elarton Close, because it must be about time to give up on him.


LA  dh: Hillenbrand    J.Rivera Considering Rivera’s serious leg break, Hillendbrand will certainly have a starting job until Rivera returns – which could be early or mid season. The Angels have loads of potential to squeeze Hillenbrand out of a job, but for now, he is fairly safe.


LA  5s: incl. Colon    incl. Jered Weaver As with Maroth and Verlander, both sites list these in both rotations. This time Rotoworld could plead the “youthful arm” defence by having the young phenomenon 5th. With Colon’s health concerns, though, he is far more likely to lose starts to co-5th starter Joe Saunders.


Min 3b: Cirillo        Punto

Rotoworld: Punto earned the job. Cirillo is 37 and just hanging on.


Min 5s: neither        incl. Baker and Ponson

Rotoworld: Who the heck is 3.92 AA pitcher Glen Perkins to walk away with a job over Baker or Ponson?


NY  1b: A.Phillips     Mientkiewicz

Rotoworld. The Yankees have made it clear Mientkie is the larger platoon half.


NY  5s: Igawa          Karstens, Proctor, Rasner As Rotoworld lists no 4th starter, this must be an electronic typo.


Oak 1b: Swisher        D.Johnson

Oak lf: Kielty         Swisher

Rotoworld: Close, but this is how I would do it. I’m not sure if has some inside knowledge here, however.


Oak 5s: no one         Kennedy, Windsor, Halsey, and Saarloos

Rotoworld: Unless Oakland plans to stick to a four man rotation, Rotoworld wins by default.


TB  1b: Norton         Wigginton

Rotoworld. I’d believe Upton before Norton.


TB  sp: no Seo         Seo is 3s

Rotoworld. Really, after Kazmir, they’re all 5rh starters. Seo certainly deserves mention.


Tex 5s: Koronka        Volquez, Rheinecker, & Cruceta

Rotoworld: To continue with Koronka would be suicide. At least, the Rotoworld trio of candidates have some potential.


Tor 5s: no Towers      incl. Towers

Rotoworld: Jays have plenty of room for a possible Towers comeback.


Rotoworld wins in 15 out of 19 comparisons. They agreed completely on only Boston and Seattle’s starters. So, for the accuracy of Rotoworld and for getting around their wonky index and making access to their depth charts as easy as possible, you should build a direct link to each team in your “favorites:” folder. Just cut and paste this link into a shortcut for each team, except change the team from BAL to BOS, CWS, CLE, DET, KC, MLB (for Angels), MIN, NYY, OAK, SEA, TB, TEX, TOR, ATL, ARZ, CHC, CIN, COL, FLA, HOU, LA, MIL, NYM, PHI, PIT, SD, SF, or WAS as appropriate. Once you’ve built your team depth chart folder, you will find how clearly this is the way to do things. Just remember, please, I told you so.


John Carter